Ne ne ne Nene

The Minister of Finance, unlikely hero and protector of the public purse, has slipped precipitously in public affections as he apologised for visiting the Guptas while Deputy Minister and his son appeared to be at the centre of a scandal at the PIC, the institution for which the Deputy Minister of Finance is responsible – here’s the not bad but turgid M&G on the son’s story and the sneering rejections of the apology from a Sunday Times contributor here.

So what we have here is THE hero of the fight against Zuma, the nuclear programme and the pillaging of SAA who was smashed out of the way by Zuma so he (Zuma) could get his hand on the national coffers. The rumpled guard who stood his lonely duty against impossible odds is now grist for the mill of the self-righteous press and the inane twittering of social media. For crimes and misdemeanors he may – or may not – have committed well before he took his vorpal sword in hand and did some snicker-snack, but not enough to kill the beast, he must be sent, besmirched, unworthy, into the outer darkness.

He’s a good metaphor if nothing else. Be careful of questions you ask, because the truth might not be what you want to hear.

We have set up the Zondo and Nugent commissions that will (hopefully) dig and dig until the slaughtered bodies and tortured truths of the Zuma pillage are dragged into the harsh light. I expect many heroes to be exposed to have old blood on their hands.

Zuma’s campaign with the Gupta’s was not the first attempt at state capture, only the best organised and most ambitious. From Sarafina II to the Strategic Defense Package the clay-footed heroes of our revolution are waiting in their serried ranks to be exposed. (Read Anthony Butler’s interesting piece, The Treasury has always been embattled, its ministers always horse traders.)

It looks like Zondo and Nugent will actually do their jobs, unlike the execrable Sereti, either a bumbler or a crook, and that means we have chosen a path entirely unlike the Sereti cover-up.

The Hawks and SAPS will have to follow the evidence. The wrongdoers will have to be punished.

If I had to guess I would say there were very, very few central leaders of the ANC who have not, at least, lifted a finger to help a friend or family member. And even if they are the best of the lot, they too face the inexorable processes that have been begun and will endlessly unwind the complex webs until the many secrets unravel and are visible gossamer in the wind.

Well good luck with that. It’s not as if there is a generation of ANC – or any other political party – leaders waiting in the wings, technocrats and professionals, to fill the hole that will be left in our political and administrative leadership.

If Nene is the standard for the kind of traitor the bright and clever twitterati believes should resign and be punished for his crimes – and they are right, the law says so, the constitution says so, nobody is above judgement and they are all, all honourable tweeters – then we might have a small human resources problem.

In the real world government, the ANC, the legislature, the executive and the judiciary – as well as the 4th, 5th, and 700th estate (which is about where social media lives) will have to find a way to draw a line, either in time of offence or quality of offense. Below the line you get a slap on the wrist, above the line you face fines, prison and banishment from public work. Without such a line – one that might be impossible to draw – the smallanyana skeletons will make everyone ineligible for office of any kind.

I don’t know how to solve this problem. My instincts are to make a “political solution”, which means my instincts are to sacrifice principle for workability. But I don’t know if that might do irreparable damage to our constitutional democracy. It’s either the iron law or its negotiable, I don’t know which is worse.

Nene reminds me of Boromir of JRR Tolkien’s Lord of the Rings. He’s a great warrior of Gondor, valiant and steadfast, but already corrupted by his temptation to use the One Ring in the war against Sauron and, unforgivably, guilty of trying to wrest it from Frodo. But now he stands facing the Uruk-hai, the sort of Orc spetsnaz. He dies as the hero he was, sprouting thick orc arrows and the bodies of the dead around him as he gives his friends a chance to escape.

Both Nene and Gordhan are plumpish and don’t really fit the image of swords and sorcery heroes gallantly protecting the public coffers from the Zuma Orcs sent in waves against them. But they stood fast and are standing still. South Africa will remember them in myth and song, fractured heroes who held the fragile line.

9 thoughts on “Ne ne ne Nene

  1. Thank you Nick, this is a breath of fresh air. Cast that stone if you have never made a mistake / misjudgment comes to mind, when I think of the twittereens and everyone else throwing Nene under the bus.

    He had some immense pressures under which he had to make do. Lost his job and reputation.

    I can only have respect for his steadfastness in not taking the easy way out when he could have done it so easily, yet chose not to.

    In THIS particular case, I’ll take this fractured hero and negotiate the law. Experiences he has gained, we need in SA.

  2. You’re a superstar and such a good writer well done think the way you explain open the eyes and understanding about this country and were it stands greatful to be a recipient of your blog thank you Nic!

  3. All I can say from this vast distance is thank you for letting us know. We need to be informed even if we are aged and unable to do much except pass it on. I have that optimism that truth and a bit of justice will prevail. I will send to anyone I know who may want to be informed. Regards Valerie Bijl.

  4. Nene, like every other ANC MP, is at least guilty of covering up Corruptheid, albeit as a captive of their Caucus. His standing up to JZ783 and the Guptas parallels Winnie’s stand against apartheid. Both acts of heroism sullied by their participation in illegalities.

    While the ANC insists that all whites benefited from Apartheid, they are blind to seeing that all ANC are benefiting from Corruptheid.

    What this illustrates is that a democracy needs checks and balances; the greater the power of the rulers, the stronger these checks and balances need to be.

  5. Balance, balance, balance.
    “He is guilty and must go”, but on the other hand Darren, “He met and saw and then took on Zuma and corruption. Why?
    Do we really know Mene’s heart? Could he be similar to David, of the Old Testament, who messed up often but his heart was good and listened to God, and God forgave him?

  6. Hi Nic Trust this finds you well Many thanks – as usual, a very thought provoking article and where do we draw the line or when will it end? Take care Kind regards Trevor

  7. Hi Nic,
    I trust you are keeping well and us other well economists informed. I have a request which you should only agree to if it really fits in easily into your programme and preferences.
    I am a member of a group of mostly retired guys eating & drinking once a month in or near Stellenbosch. The group consist of Guy Steyn (Business man, previous chair of Stellenbosch University board), Gerhard van Niekerk (ex Old Mutual), Gerhard Swiegers (ex MediClinic), Nick Terblanche (Emiritus prof Stellenbosch) and Frans Malan (winemaker) and perhaps also Rudolf Gouws (this time). Our next meet is Thursday 18th (normally at 12:30) at a restaurant I still have to identify. So the request is for you to join in as our guest and to talk informally around the table about our politics and where it may be going. I don’t have a budget but can provide a box of Eikendal red to cover your transport costs.
    Please let me know.
    Best regards

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: